Check Valve Selection: How to Make the Best Choice

02 Dec.,2024

 

Check Valve Selection: How to Make the Best Choice

Selecting the right check valve is essential to ensure the smooth operation of the entire system. A mismatched valve can lead to issues such as leaks, system failure, reduced efficiency, or increased maintenance costs. The material of the valve, its size, pressure rating, and compatibility with the media it handles are all critical factors that affect performance and reliability.

Link to BSTV

Types of Check Valves  

Swing Check Valve

Design, Mechanics, and Common Uses:

A swing check valve consists of a hinged disc that swings open when fluid flows in the correct direction and closes when the flow reverses. The disc&#;s movement relies on gravity or the flow&#;s pressure differential to control backflow. Swing check valves are typically used in systems with horizontal flow. They are commonly found in water treatment systems, oil and gas pipelines, and HVAC applications due to their simple yet effective design.

Advantages:

Simple design with fewer moving parts, resulting in lower maintenance requirements.

Suitable for applications involving large volumes of fluid.

Minimal pressure drop during normal operation.

Disadvantages:

The large disc swing can cause water hammer in fast-closing systems.

Not ideal for applications with low flow or frequent flow reversals.

Limited to horizontal installation, which can be a constraint in some systems.

Ball Check Valve

Construction, Function, and Typical Applications:

Ball check valves consist of a spherical ball that moves back and forth within a chamber to block or allow fluid flow. When the fluid flows in the correct direction, the pressure pushes the ball off its seat, allowing flow. When flow reverses, the ball returns to its seat, preventing backflow. These valves are compact, making them suitable for systems with limited space. Ball check valves are often used in applications like wastewater treatment, chemical processing, and small pumps.

Pros:

Compact design makes them ideal for tight spaces.

Effective in applications with low-pressure systems and low-flow conditions.

Simple operation with minimal maintenance needs.

Cons:

Limited ability to handle high-pressure applications.

More prone to wear if exposed to corrosive or abrasive media over time.

The ball can stick if not properly maintained, leading to malfunction.

Lift Check Valve

Operating Principles, Benefits, and Common Industry Uses:

Lift check valves use a disc that moves vertically within a guide. When fluid flows in the correct direction, the disc lifts to allow flow, and when flow reverses, gravity or a spring pushes the disc back into its seat to stop reverse flow. Lift check valves are ideal for applications with frequent flow changes or high-pressure systems such as steam, gas, and chemical pipelines.

Benefits:

Handles high pressure effectively.

The vertical design allows installation in systems with vertical piping.

Common Industry Uses:

Steam and gas pipelines, high-pressure water systems, and industrial process systems.

Diaphragm Check Valve

How It Works, Specific Applications, and Pros/Cons:

A diaphragm check valve uses a flexible diaphragm to control flow. When fluid flows in the correct direction, the diaphragm deforms, allowing fluid to pass. When the flow reverses, the diaphragm returns to its normal position, blocking the reverse flow. These valves are used in systems handling corrosive media, slurry, or sanitary applications.

Pros:

Resistant to corrosion, making them ideal for chemical and sanitary applications.

Provides a tight seal with minimal leakage risk.

Works well with abrasive and viscous fluids.

Cons:

Limited to low-pressure applications.

Diaphragm materials may degrade over time, requiring replacement.

Piston Check Valve

Best Use Cases and Effectiveness in Certain Conditions:

Piston check valves utilize a piston that moves within a cylinder to block or allow flow. These valves are well-suited for systems where precise control of flow is needed, such as hydraulic and gas applications. The piston design allows for better sealing under high-pressure conditions, and it prevents reverse flow efficiently.

Best Use Cases:

Ideal for high-pressure hydraulic systems, natural gas processing, and petrochemical industries.

Why Effective:

Piston check valves provide exceptional sealing capabilities, preventing leakage even in high-pressure environments.

Suitable for applications where system integrity and pressure control are critical.

Wafer Check Valve

Slim Design, Installation Advantages, and Limitations:

Wafer check valves are known for their compact, slim design that allows them to fit into tight spaces within a pipeline. They have a thin, lightweight body, making them easy to install between flanges. This makes them an excellent choice for systems with limited space. Wafer check valves are often used in water, HVAC, and industrial fluid systems.

Advantages:

Space-saving design is suitable for compact systems.

Easy installation between existing pipe flanges without the need for additional support.

Minimal pressure drop during operation.

Limitations:

Limited range of media compatibility (not ideal for highly corrosive or abrasive substances).

Cannot handle extreme pressures or temperatures as well as other types.

Foot Valve

Role in Pump Applications and Benefits for Suction Lines:

A foot valve is essentially a type of check valve installed at the intake of a pump. It has a strainer that prevents debris from entering the pump while allowing fluid to flow in one direction only, preventing reverse flow. Foot valves are commonly used in water pumps and irrigation systems to maintain the pump&#;s prime and prevent backflow into the suction line.

Benefits:

Keeps pumps primed, reducing the need for re-priming and ensuring efficient operation.

Prevents the intake of debris, protecting the pump from damage.

Dual Plate Check Valve

Efficiency in High-Flow Applications and Pressure Relief Capabilities:

Dual plate check valves consist of two half-circle plates that pivot on a central hinge. When fluid flows in the correct direction, the plates open, allowing flow. When the flow reverses, the plates close, preventing backflow. These valves are known for their efficiency in high-flow and high-pressure applications, such as in the oil and gas industry, chemical processing, and power generation plants.

Efficiency in High-Flow Applications:

The two-plate design minimizes turbulence and pressure loss, making them highly efficient for high-flow systems.

They offer quick closing action, reducing the risk of water hammer.

Pressure Relief Capabilities:

Dual plate check valves are designed to handle high-pressure conditions effectively, making them ideal for systems with fluctuating flow rates or where pressure surges are common.

Key Factors in Check Valve Selection  

Selecting the right check valve is critical to ensuring optimal performance and longevity in hydraulic and industrial systems. When choosing a check valve, various factors come into play, including material selection, pressure and temperature ratings, flow rate, valve size, installation orientation, media type, and maintenance requirements. Each of these factors plays a significant role in determining which valve will best suit the application at hand.

Material Selection

Metallic Valves

Metallic check valves are commonly made from materials such as stainless steel, brass, and cast iron. Each metal offers specific advantages:

Stainless Steel: Known for its corrosion resistance, stainless steel is ideal for applications involving aggressive media, such as chemicals, seawater, or high-temperature fluids. Stainless steel valves are often used in food processing, chemical industries, and marine applications.

Brass: Brass valves offer a good balance between corrosion resistance and cost-effectiveness, making them popular in water systems, HVAC, and general-purpose fluid applications. Brass is easy to work with and provides adequate durability for low to moderate pressures.

Cast Iron: Cast iron check valves are typically used in larger systems that require durability but operate at lower pressures. They are commonly found in water and sewage applications where corrosion is not a significant concern.

Non-Metallic Valves

Non-metallic check valves are made from materials like PVC, plastic, and composite materials:

PVC: PVC check valves are lightweight and corrosion-resistant, making them an excellent choice for low-pressure applications such as irrigation, wastewater, and water treatment systems. They are also highly affordable and easy to install.

Plastic and Composite Materials: These valves offer superior corrosion resistance, especially in environments where aggressive chemicals or seawater are present. They are frequently used in industries such as chemical processing and pharmaceuticals where material compatibility is crucial.

Corrosion Resistance

The environment in which the valve operates heavily influences material selection. Factors such as acidity, alkalinity, or exposure to seawater can degrade certain materials faster than others. Stainless steel and non-metallic valves tend to offer the best resistance to corrosion. For highly corrosive environments, composite materials or PVC may be the best choice, while brass and cast iron may be more suitable for less aggressive environments.

Pressure and Temperature Ratings

Understanding Pressure Ratings (PSI)

Every check valve has a specific pressure rating, typically measured in pounds per square inch (PSI). The pressure rating indicates the maximum pressure the valve can withstand without failing. It is essential to select a valve with a pressure rating that matches or exceeds the system&#;s maximum pressure to avoid leaks, damage, or system failure.

Low-Pressure Applications: PVC or brass check valves often suffice for low-pressure systems such as residential plumbing or irrigation systems.

High-Pressure Applications: For systems requiring high-pressure resistance, such as hydraulic systems or chemical processing plants, stainless steel or other high-strength materials should be used.

Importance of Temperature Tolerance

Temperature variations can significantly affect valve performance. Some materials expand under high temperatures or become brittle in cold conditions, leading to leaks or failure. It is crucial to consider the operating temperature range when selecting a valve:

Thermal Expansion: Materials like stainless steel and cast iron can withstand high temperatures, making them ideal for steam or hot water systems. However, plastic or PVC valves have lower temperature tolerances and should be avoided in such applications.

The company is the world’s best Globe Valve supplier. We are your one-stop shop for all needs. Our staff are highly-specialized and will help you find the product you need.

Material Limitations: Plastic valves can deform at high temperatures, while cast iron can become brittle in freezing conditions. Understanding the thermal limitations of the valve material is essential to avoid performance issues.

Flow Rate and Velocity

Calculating Appropriate Valve Size

The size of a check valve is directly related to the flow rate it can handle. A valve that is too small will restrict flow, causing pressure drops and inefficiencies, while an oversized valve may result in poor sealing and increased wear.

Sizing Formula: Flow rate is often expressed in gallons per minute (GPM) or liters per minute (LPM). Manufacturers typically provide charts to match the correct valve size to the system&#;s flow rate. A general rule of thumb is to size the valve based on the pipe diameter, but specific calculations may be needed for more complex systems.

Relationship Between Valve Size and Flow Performance

As flow velocity increases, so does the risk of wear and tear on the valve. A valve that is too small will experience higher pressure drops and potential cavitation, while an oversized valve may not close properly, leading to backflow. Therefore, matching the valve size to the system&#;s flow requirements is critical for optimal performance.

Valve Size

How Valve Size Affects Efficiency and Cost

The physical size of the valve affects both efficiency and installation costs. Larger valves are more expensive and can be more difficult to install, especially in systems with limited space. However, undersizing a valve can lead to pressure losses and inefficiencies that outweigh the initial cost savings.

Matching Valve Size with Piping Dimensions and System Demand

To ensure proper system performance, the valve must match the size of the piping it is installed in. Additionally, it should be able to handle the system&#;s demand for flow and pressure. Failure to size the valve correctly can result in operational inefficiencies and increased maintenance.

Installation Orientation

Vertical vs. Horizontal Installation

Many check valves are designed for horizontal installations, but some, like lift check valves, work better in vertical setups. The installation orientation can impact the valve&#;s effectiveness:

Vertical Installation: Typically used for systems where gravity assists with fluid movement, such as in pump discharge systems.

Horizontal Installation: Most common in pipeline systems, where flow moves horizontally. Valves like swing and wafer check valves are often used in these orientations.

Considerations for Space Constraints and Backflow Prevention

Space constraints may dictate the use of a compact valve, such as a wafer check valve, that can be installed between flanges. Additionally, valves must be installed in the correct orientation to prevent backflow effectively. For example, a swing check valve must be installed in a horizontal line to ensure proper closure.

Media Type

Compatibility with Different Media Types

The media passing through the check valve is a significant factor in valve selection. Valves must be compatible with the type of fluid (or gas) being transported, whether it be water, oil, gas, or chemicals. Media compatibility affects both the material selection and the overall longevity of the valve.

Water and Oil: Brass or stainless steel valves are suitable for water or oil systems, where corrosion is not a significant concern.

Chemicals: Systems that transport aggressive chemicals may require plastic, composite, or stainless steel valves to prevent corrosion and degradation.

How the Media Affects Valve Wear and Tear

Abrasive media can cause excessive wear on valve components, leading to early failure. In such cases, selecting a valve made from highly durable materials, like stainless steel or specialized composites, is necessary to ensure longevity and reduce maintenance costs.

Maintenance Requirements

Ease of Maintenance and Repair Over the Valve&#;s Lifespan

The ease with which a valve can be maintained or repaired significantly impacts its long-term costs. Valves that require frequent disassembly or replacement of parts can increase system downtime and maintenance costs.

Designing for Easy Access and Low-Cost Maintenance

Some valve designs allow for easier access to internal components, making it easier to conduct inspections and repairs without fully removing the valve from the system. Wafer check valves, for example, are relatively easy to maintain because of their compact design, while more complex valves like piston check valves may require more intricate maintenance procedures.

Common Mistakes When Selecting Check Valves

Selecting the right check valve is crucial to ensuring efficient system operation and preventing costly failures. However, several common mistakes can lead to performance issues and increased maintenance costs. Below are some of the most frequent errors made when choosing check valves.

Oversizing or Undersizing Valves

One of the most common mistakes is selecting a check valve that is either too large or too small for the application. Oversized valves may not close properly because the flow rate is too low, leading to backflow or leakage. This is especially problematic in low-flow systems where the valve cannot generate enough force to close completely.

Conversely, undersizing a check valve can cause excessive pressure drops and flow restrictions. A valve that is too small will restrict fluid movement, reducing system efficiency and potentially damaging equipment due to increased system strain.

Solution:

Always match the valve size to the flow rate and pipe diameter to ensure optimal performance. Using flow rate charts and consulting manufacturers&#; guidelines can help prevent this mistake.

Ignoring Pressure and Temperature Limits

Each check valve has specific pressure and temperature limits, and exceeding these limits can result in catastrophic failure. For example, using a valve in a high-pressure system that is only rated for low pressures may cause the valve to burst or leak. Similarly, installing a valve that cannot withstand the operating temperature of the system can lead to thermal expansion, material degradation, or cracking.

Consequences:

Leaks and system failure due to overpressure.

Cracking or warping of valve components under extreme temperatures.

Solution:

Select a valve with pressure and temperature ratings that exceed the system&#;s maximum operating conditions to ensure safety and longevity.

Choosing the Wrong Material

Selecting a check valve made from incompatible materials is a common mistake that can lead to corrosion, cracking, or material deterioration. For example, using a brass valve in a system with corrosive chemicals can cause the valve to degrade rapidly. Similarly, a plastic valve might crack if used in a high-pressure or high-temperature environment.

Risks:

Material failure due to corrosion, especially in chemical or marine environments.

Shortened valve lifespan and increased maintenance costs.

Solution:

Match the valve material to the specific environmental and media conditions. For corrosive or aggressive fluids, use stainless steel, composite materials, or other corrosion-resistant options.

Neglecting Media Characteristics

Another common error is neglecting the specific characteristics of the media flowing through the system. Different fluids have different properties, such as viscosity, abrasiveness, and chemical composition, which can affect valve performance. For example, using a valve designed for water in a system transporting abrasive fluids can cause premature wear and tear.

Problems:

Excessive wear due to abrasive fluids.

Valve malfunction when incompatible with media characteristics (e.g., chemical incompatibility).

Solution:

Understand the media&#;s characteristics and select a valve that can withstand those conditions. Consult with manufacturers for recommendations on valve types and materials suited to specific media.

Inadequate Consideration of Installation Environment

Failing to consider the environmental conditions in which the valve will be installed is another common mistake. Valves exposed to harsh conditions, such as extreme temperatures, high humidity, or corrosive environments, require materials and designs that can withstand these factors. For instance, a valve installed in an outdoor marine environment may require additional protection against corrosion and temperature changes.

Importance:

Exposure to environmental factors like moisture, salt, or extreme temperatures can degrade the valve and cause performance issues.

Solution:

Factor in the location and environmental conditions when selecting the valve. Choose materials that can withstand the installation environment to ensure reliable operation.

How to Make the Best Choice

Define Application and Media Requirements

The first step in selecting a check valve is to define the specific application and media requirements. Consider the nature of the system in which the valve will be used, such as whether it is a hydraulic system, water treatment plant, or chemical processing unit. Also, determine the type of media that will flow through the valve. Is it liquid, gas, abrasive, or corrosive? Understanding the application and the media characteristics will help narrow down the valve options and ensure compatibility.

Key Questions to Ask:

Is the system handling water, chemicals, oil, or gas?

Will the media be abrasive or corrosive?

Does the application require precise control or large-volume flow?

Assess System Pressure, Temperature, and Flow Needs

Next, evaluate the system&#;s pressure and temperature requirements. Ensure the check valve you select can handle the maximum operating pressure and temperature without compromising its integrity. Flow rate is another crucial factor; the valve should match the system&#;s flow rate to avoid issues like turbulence, cavitation, or excessive pressure drop.

Important Considerations:

Maximum system pressure and temperature.

Flow rate (measured in GPM or LPM) to determine valve size.

Pressure drop requirements for maintaining system efficiency.

Determine Material and Sizing Requirements

Once you&#;ve assessed the application, media, pressure, and temperature, you can choose the appropriate material for your valve. For instance, stainless steel might be ideal for high-pressure and corrosive environments, while PVC could work well in lower-pressure applications with non-corrosive media. Additionally, ensure the valve is sized correctly. An improperly sized valve can lead to performance issues, such as excessive wear or improper sealing.

Material Selection: Choose based on corrosion resistance, temperature tolerance, and media compatibility (e.g., stainless steel, brass, PVC).

Sizing: Match valve size to the system&#;s pipe diameter and flow rate requirements.

Identify Specific Check Valve Type Based on Application

Different check valve types are suited for specific applications. A swing check valve is ideal for systems with high flow rates and minimal turbulence, while a ball check valve works well in low-flow or compact systems. Diaphragm check valves are best for sanitary applications or when handling corrosive media. Carefully match the check valve type to your system&#;s operational needs.

Valve Types:

Swing Check Valve: Good for large-flow applications.

Ball Check Valve: Compact design for low-pressure systems.

Lift Check Valve: Works well in vertical installations.

Diaphragm Check Valve: Ideal for corrosive or sanitary environments

Conclusion

To make the best choice, apply the step-by-step valve selection process outlined in this guide. Define your application and media requirements, assess system parameters, and consult sizing and material charts to ensure compatibility. For more complex systems or uncertain scenarios, consult with industry experts or suppliers who can provide valuable insights and technical support.

FAQ

What is a check valve used for?

A check valve is used to allow fluid or gas to flow in one direction while preventing reverse flow, ensuring system integrity and preventing damage.

How do I choose the right material for a check valve?

The material should be chosen based on the type of media (e.g., water, chemicals, oil), the operating temperature, and the environment. Common materials include stainless steel, brass, and PVC.

What factors should I consider when sizing a check valve?

Consider the system&#;s flow rate, pipe diameter, and pressure requirements to ensure the valve size matches the system&#;s capacity and avoids inefficiencies.

What happens if a check valve is undersized?

An undersized check valve can cause flow restrictions, pressure drops, and inefficient system performance, potentially leading to equipment damage.

Can check valves be installed vertically?

Yes, some check valves, such as lift check valves, can be installed vertically, but others, like swing check valves, typically perform better in horizontal installations.

How often should a check valve be inspected?

Check valves should be inspected regularly as part of routine maintenance to ensure they are functioning correctly, especially in high-pressure or corrosive environments.